judgesonmerit.org

Governor Rendell’s second slate of nominees to fill interim vacancies on the appellate courts has been confirmed by the state Senate. Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Judge Jane Cutler Greenspan will serve on the Supreme Court; McKean County President Judge John Cleland and Northampton County President Judge Robert Freedberg will serve on the Superior Court; and Philadelphia lawyer Johnny Butler will serve on the Commonwealth Court. The judges will serve until January 2010, when new judges elected in the fall 2009 elections will be sworn in. The newly confirmed judges each have pledged not to run for full terms in the 2009 elections.

Filling these vacancies was a long and politically contentious process. Although the new judges, like the previous nominees, are highly regarded, the process by which they came to the bench was not Merit Selection. There are two major differences between the current interim appointment process and Merit Selection.

First, the current process does not use an independent nominating commission to evaluate candidates and recommend the most qualified to the Governor. Instead, the Governor, working with legislative leaders, devises a list of candidates.

Second, the current process does not involve a role for the public. Under Merit Selection, after the judge serves for a brief initial term, the public votes in a retention election on whether or not the judge should continue in office. By contrast, in the current interim appointment process, the judges serve only for a short time and pledge not to seek a full term. This is the political deal that must be made to secure confirmation, and it deprives the public of an opportunity to evaluate the judges and of longer service by good judges.

We are pleased that the long vacant appellate court seats will be filled, but we regret that we are still using a political process that is part and parcel of the electoral system to do so.